Skip to main content

The Fictional War on Christmas



            In the essay “End the ‘War on Christmas’” Edward Grinnan (p. 421) argues that the conflict known as “The War on Christmas” is a foolish argument and a “ceasefire” should be declared over the conflict. Grinnan argues that the holiday itself has roots in pagan culture and was adapted into Christian culture in order to persuade those who lived in their own society into joining Christianity. Also comparing the “War” to that of a “bickering old married couple” that they are arguing about the topic without any side reaching an agreement. Grinnan cites a story published in Guidepost regarding an incident on Christmas Eve during World War I in which the opposing sides in the war spent the night singing carols to one another instead of fighting only to resume “killing each other” in the morning. Grinnan concludes saying that the argument between religious and non-religious groups over the holiday is redundant since it has “vaguely pagan origins” as well as pointing out the public’s over “commercialization” of the holiday. Also explaining, that everyone should embrace the “joy and light and peace,” that comes from celebrating the holiday which is something we could all agree on.
            The war on Christmas is fictional at best considering the ever growing holiday season. In 2012 the holiday shopping season started on Thanksgiving making it black Thursday instead of starting on the traditional black Friday. The beginning of the holiday season has been the Friday after thanksgiving since the mid 1900’s marking the official start with sales in shopping centers as well as families beginning to trim their trees the on this day. It is not commonly known to those who don’t work in retail but most stores and shopping centers begin receiving holiday shipments as early as mid-July to early August. Grinnan’s assessment about the over commercialization of the holiday is correct because people have seen the holiday season as a way to get the best deals on products that are generally expensive during the rest of the year.
            There is also the aspect of the media’s and network television’s involvement by airing movies and specials during the Christmas season. Television networks such as ABC Family air several holiday specials as well as the highly publicized “25 Days of Christmas” when they’ll air Christmas movies from the first of December until Christmas Day. Networks rarely air specials for any other holiday during this season even though Hanukah and Kwanza are a part of the season. Grinnan states that “the separation between church and state can sometimes blur,” this is also something that is addressed every year since the President and the White House have a long standing tradition of their own holiday special that airs on cable television every year. Even though the President shows support towards all holidays it is widely known that the white house is mostly covered in Christmas decorations during the season.
            The constant argument of the so called war on Christmas truly is fictional when just walking down New York City’s infamous Fifth Avenue which is covered in decorations all the way down to Rockefeller Plaza where the traditional Christmas tree is hung every year.  There’s even a big snowflake that hangs on Fifth Avenue while men dressed in Santa suits stand at every corner asking for Christmas donations. Grinnan’s assessment that “at its golden heart Christmas is an embracing of joy and light and peace, something I think everyone can agree to celebrate together” is true to most Americans who walk through light covered streets and sing carols while sitting together at home during the holiday. Yet the true question should be is there an actual war on the holiday? Once a person looks around the real answer is no, the only war that is being waged on Christmas is a war of words between opposing sides for a greater equality for all other religions who don’t celebrate this mass marketed holiday.


Works Cited

Labels

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Montresor’s Downfall A Psychoanalytical look at Edgar Allan Poe’s The Cask of Amontillado

            Psychoanalytic Criticism is an approach of critical thought that follows “how and why people behave the way they do,” this theory is practiced in more than one field outside of literature. Some theories have been developed alongside other literary theories and those have been further developed by different theorist. Psychoanalysis as a school of literary theory can focus on one or more than one aspect of a literary work by focusing on the author, a specific character, the literary text, and even the audience that is reading the text. The most famous critic of psychoanalysis is Sigmund Freud who developed the original theory consisting of the unconscious mind, the desires of a person or character, and a defense. Freud further developed this into the id, the ego and the superego. Each of these aspects of the theory is dominated by a particular aspect; the id is dominated by pleasure, the ego is dominated by realit...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Eye Sees Everything Psychoanalysis and The Tell Tale Heart

            Psychoanalysis is one of the most well-known critical approaches in literature, it shows the literary critic the mental state of not only the main character, but the author as well. In the book Critical Theory Today , Lois Tyson describes psychoanalytic criticism as “The notion that human beings are motivated even driven by desires, fears, needs, and conflicts of which they are unaware – that is, unconscious.” (Tyson, 12) This theoretical approach was created by Sigmund Freud from his theories on the unconscious mind and that people repress the things they don’t want to remember and that they go through several stages when they trying to repress memories. Almost as if a person is dealing with the five stages of grief, the stages of repression follow a similar pattern these stages include selective “perception, selective memory, denial, avoidance, displacement, and projection.” (15) These stages come from what a ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Psychoanalysis and Hamlet

Note: I feel like this is probably not my best paper but I'm posting it anyway.             Hamlet is considered one of the most flawed characters in English Literature. After the death of his father, and his mother remarrying immediately afterwards to of all people his Uncle Claudius, Hamlet is pushed towards the brink trying to deal with all of these sudden changes. All of these changes put together can create instability in Hamlet’s mind as his world is shaken by the sudden changes. When psychoanalyst Sigmund Freud wrote T he Interpretation of Dreams he introduced the world to the ideas of the id , the ego and the superego in which encompass the way the mind is influenced by events from their younger years. Freud said that “the predominantly passionate, irrational, unknown, and unconscious part of the psyche the id, or “it.” The ego, or “I,” was his term for the predominantly rational, logical, orderly, conscious par...
Post a Comment
Read more